Based on my profession, it should come as no surprise that I am a big fan of supporting charities and people committed to community service. However, I have to confess. I have a big problem with the folks who stand on the median strip asking for money for the designated charity of the rush hour! Here’s what gets me:
Do we really know who these folks are? At one intersection, you have people who appear to be fresh-faced college kids with their university logos emblazoned across their sweat shirts holding up plastic buckets asking for donations to support pediatric cancer research. Sometimes they morph into people dressed up like fire fighters — right down to their boots and suspenders. They hold buckets or fire hats (nice touch!) asking for contributions to keep the firehouse running. Other times, these folks seem to be athletes of some kind with team shirts and caps who are looking for support to go on a team trip.
Look, I love college kids, firefighters, and team sports. Cancer research is a great cause to support — as are all the others. My problem is this: are these people legitimate? Are they really who they say they are? Are they truly collecting money for the causes they have hand written on paper that has been taped to various containers? How do we know the money makes it from the bucket to the organization?
When I give money to a cause, I wanted to be assured of a few things: Is the organization that is getting my money reputable? Will my donation support the mission of the program rather than administrative expenses such as rent or travel?
There are, numerous ways to know if a fundraising effort is worth your donation. When I get a direct mail piece, a fundraising phone call, an invitation to an event, or read about a cause, I can use online services like Guidestar, Charity Navigator, or the Wise Giving Guide to make sure that the charity gets high marks.
But when I am in my car waiting for the light to change from red to green, I don’t have time to roll down my window and ask these questions. It wouldn’t be safe driving to pull out my iPad and google the charity to try to confirm the legitimacy of the fundraising effort.
Here’s the other part of the dilemma. Many times when I am driving by, I have my daughter in the car. She wants to know, “Who are they mom? Why aren’t we stopping? Cant’ we help them?” Of course I explain who I think they are and that they appear to be asking for donations. But I also feel compelled to let her know that I am not 100% certain about the situation – and perhaps she should not be either.
Am I turning my daughter into a cynic at an early age? Or am I just trying to teach her that sometimes a smile and a “please” and a hand written sign is not enough to earn our trust and get us to open our wallets? There are so many worthy causes that rely on our support. And I applaud fundraisers. However, in regard to the “roadside ask,” I just wish that the method used for getting donations did not put into question the authenticity of the effort! What do you think?
©YesKidzCan!, 2011